Privacy & security
VPN vs proxy
How VPNs and proxies differ in encryption, privacy and speed.
Updated · First published · 8 sources
The short answer
A VPN encrypts all the traffic leaving your device and sends it through the VPN server. A proxy relays traffic only for the apps set up to use it, and a basic HTTP or SOCKS5 proxy doesn’t encrypt the link between you and the proxy. Both hide your IP address from the sites you visit, but only a VPN covers your whole device and hides your activity from the network you’re on.
How does a VPN work?
A VPN app creates an encrypted tunnel from your device to a server run by the VPN company. The EFF describes it as encrypting and sending “all internet data” from your computer through that server. Your Wi-Fi network and internet provider see only encrypted traffic to the VPN, and websites see the VPN server’s IP address instead of yours.
How does a proxy work?
A proxy is a server that passes requests on your behalf. Microsoft’s Windows help puts it simply: a proxy “routes your internet traffic through an intermediary”. Websites see the proxy’s IP address, not yours.
The difference is scope. A proxy works at the level of an app, not the whole device: you point a browser, a torrent client or a game launcher at it, and only traffic from apps that use the proxy goes through it.
Common types of proxy
- Web proxy: a website you type addresses into. It only covers pages loaded through it.
- HTTP or HTTPS proxy: set in your browser or system settings, mainly for web traffic.
- SOCKS5: a general-purpose proxy defined in RFC 1928. It can relay any TCP or UDP traffic from an app that supports it, often with a username and password login. It doesn’t encrypt traffic by default.
What are the main differences?
- Coverage: a VPN covers every app on the device once it’s on. A proxy covers only the apps configured to use it.
- Encryption: a VPN encrypts everything between you and its server. A basic HTTP or SOCKS5 proxy doesn’t; anyone on your network can see which sites you ask it for.
- Who sees your traffic: either way, the operator of the server can see your real IP address and where you go.
- Setup: a VPN is an app you switch on. A proxy is an address and port you type into each app.
- Cost: proxies are often free, but you rarely know who runs a free one or what it does with your data.
Is an unencrypted proxy dangerous?
Less than it used to be. The FTC notes that most websites now use encryption, shown by https and a lock in the address bar. On those sites, the contents of your pages, passwords and payments stay encrypted even through a proxy.
What a plain proxy doesn’t hide is which sites you visit: your local network and the proxy can both see that. Any site or app that still uses unencrypted http is fully exposed. A VPN closes both gaps between you and its server, although the VPN company itself can see the same things, which is why its logging policy matters.
Are browser “VPNs” and Private Relay proxies?
Mostly, yes. They encrypt the link to their servers, but they mainly cover the browser.
- Firefox’s built-in VPN routes browser traffic through “a secure proxy server”. Mozilla says it only masks traffic that originates in Firefox and doesn’t protect other apps. It needs a Mozilla account, is only available in selected regions and has a 50 GB monthly data limit.
- Apple’s iCloud Private Relay protects browsing in Safari. It sends requests through two separate relays, so the Apple-run relay sees your IP address and a second, third-party relay connects you to the site with a temporary address. Your DNS lookups are encrypted too. It’s part of an iCloud+ subscription and isn’t available in every country or region.
These are good for private browsing. They don’t protect your email app, games or other software, which a full VPN does.
Will a VPN or a proxy get past streaming blocks?
Streaming services treat them the same way. Netflix’s error message is literally “You seem to be using a VPN or proxy”, and it asks you to turn it off. Some VPNs keep working with some services, and that changes often; our streaming guide explains what to expect.
When should you use a VPN, and when a proxy?
Use a VPN when
- You want everything on your device covered, not just the browser.
- You’re on a network you don’t trust and want to hide which sites and services you use.
- You’re torrenting; see torrenting safely with a VPN for the settings that matter.
A proxy is enough when
- You only need one app to appear from a different IP address, and the sites it uses run on https.
- Your school or workplace requires one to reach the internet.
- You only want private browsing in Firefox or Safari, and their built-in option is available to you: Firefox’s in your region, within its 50 GB monthly limit, or Private Relay through an iCloud+ subscription.
Whichever you choose, you’re trusting the operator with your traffic. Prefer a provider whose no-logs policy has been independently audited; see what a no-logs policy means.
Common questions
Is a VPN better than a proxy?
For privacy and security, yes: a VPN encrypts all your device’s traffic, while a basic proxy covers one app and doesn’t encrypt the connection to it. A proxy can still be enough to change one app’s IP address.
Does a proxy hide my IP address?
Yes, from the sites you visit, for the apps that use it. The proxy operator still sees your real IP address.
Is a SOCKS5 proxy encrypted?
Not by default. SOCKS5 relays traffic for any app that supports it, but encryption only comes from the app itself, such as a site using https.
Is a proxy faster than a VPN?
Not reliably. A proxy skips the VPN’s encryption, but speed depends mostly on how far away and how busy the server is, the same as with a VPN.
Is Firefox’s built-in VPN a real VPN?
Mozilla describes it as a secure proxy that only covers traffic from Firefox. It doesn’t protect other apps on your device.
Sources
We checked this guide against these pages on October 22, 2026.
- Understanding and circumventing network censorship · EFF Surveillance Self-Defense, Feb 1, 2024
- Choosing the VPN that’s right for you · EFF Surveillance Self-Defense, Jul 28, 2026
- Use a proxy server in Windows · Microsoft Support
- RFC 1928: SOCKS protocol version 5 · IETF
- Are public Wi-Fi networks safe? What you need to know · US Federal Trade Commission
- Use built-in VPN in Firefox · Mozilla Support
- About iCloud Private Relay · Apple Support, Aug 31, 2023
- Netflix says, “You seem to be using a VPN or proxy.” · Netflix Help Center