Skip to content
Data checked · Updated

Surfshark vs Private Internet Access (PIA)

Surfshark scores higher overall (8.5 vs 8.3), winning on streaming, speed. Private Internet Access (PIA) is ahead on privacy & trust, value.

Surfshark8.5/10

#3 of 6 overall · wins this matchup

Visit Surfshark

Criterion by criterion

Where each one wins

7.0
Privacy & trust
8.5

PIA scores higher (8.5 vs 7.0). Surfshark has a no-logs audit by Deloitte (2025), is based in the Netherlands (a 14 Eyes country) and its apps aren't open source. PIA has a no-logs audit by Deloitte (2025), is based in the United States (a 14 Eyes country) and its apps are open source.

8.1
Speed
7.5

Surfshark scores higher (8.1 vs 7.5). Surfshark lost 9.6% of download speed and PIA 12.7% in Gizmodo's tests (October 2026), run on the same connection for both. Lower is better.

9.4
Value
10.0

PIA scores higher (10.0 vs 9.4). Surfshark costs $2.49/mo on its 2-year plan (+3 months free, Black Friday deal price), $67.23 upfront, then renews at $79.00/year. PIA costs $2.03/mo on its 3-year plan (+4 months free, Early Access Sale price), $81.20 upfront, then renews at $81.20 every 3 years ($27.07/year). Both cover unlimited devices; both give 30 days to ask for a refund.

8.9
Security features
8.9

Both score 8.9 for security features. Only Surfshark has multi-hop. Only PIA has port forwarding.

9.2
Streaming
3.1

Surfshark scores higher (9.2 vs 3.1). In the latest independent tests we track, Surfshark unblocked 10 of the 11 services and PIA 4; a service without a recent test counts as not unblocked (neither has one for Apple TV). Only Surfshark: Prime Video, Hulu, HBO Max, Paramount+, ESPN (no recent test for PIA) and DAZN. Surfshark officially supports watching your home library while traveling; PIA doesn't support that under its terms. The score gives credit for that travel policy too.

10.0
Apps & support
10.0

Both score 10.0 for apps & support. Both support Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, Android TV, Fire TV, Apple TV, routers and Chromebook. Both offer 24/7 live chat.

SurfsharkPrivate Internet Access (PIA)

Side by side

The numbers

Better value marked with a dot.

FactSurfsharkPrivate Internet Access (PIA)
Best price$2.49/mo$2.03/mo
Upfront bill$67.23 / 27 mo$81.20 / 40 mo
Month-to-month$18.95$11.95
Renews at$79.00/yr$81.20 / 3 yrs
Money-back30 days30 days
DevicesUnlimitedUnlimited
Speed loss9.6%12.7%
AuditDeloitte 2025Deloitte 2025
JurisdictionNetherlandsUnited States
Open sourceNoYes
Servers3,20029,650
Countries10091
Port forwardingNoYes

Prices checked Nov 9, 2026 (Surfshark) and Nov 9, 2026 (Private Internet Access (PIA)).

Verdict

Which one should you pick?

Choose Surfshark if

  • You mostly use it to stream
  • You game online
  • You travel or use public Wi-Fi a lot
  • You weigh streaming above everything else
  • You weigh speed above everything else

Choose Private Internet Access (PIA) if

  • You torrent or use P2P apps
  • Privacy is your top concern
  • You need to cover a whole household
  • You weigh privacy & trust above everything else
  • You weigh value above everything else

We earn a commission if you buy through our links. It never changes a score: rankings are computed from the data. How we make money

FAQ

Surfshark vs Private Internet Access (PIA): common questions

Which is better, Surfshark or PIA?

Surfshark scores higher overall (8.5 vs 8.3), winning on streaming, speed. Private Internet Access (PIA) is ahead on privacy & trust, value.

Is Surfshark cheaper than PIA?

PIA is cheaper on its best plan. Surfshark costs $2.49/mo on its 2-year plan (+3 months free, Black Friday deal price), $67.23 upfront, then renews at $79.00/year. PIA costs $2.03/mo on its 3-year plan (+4 months free, Early Access Sale price), $81.20 upfront, then renews at $81.20 every 3 years ($27.07/year). Month to month, Surfshark is $18.95 and PIA $11.95. At renewal, PIA is cheaper: $27.07 a year against $79.00. Prices checked November 9, 2026, in US dollars before tax.

Which is faster, Surfshark or PIA?

Surfshark was faster: Surfshark lost 9.6% of download speed and PIA 12.7% in Gizmodo's October 2026 tests. Your own speeds depend on your connection and the server you pick.

Is Surfshark or PIA better for streaming?

Surfshark unblocked more services in the latest independent tests we track (Surfshark 10, PIA 4 of 11). Both unblocked Netflix US. Streaming services block VPN servers often, so results change.

Which is more private, Surfshark or PIA?

PIA scores higher on privacy and trust (8.5 vs 7.0). Surfshark has a no-logs audit by Deloitte (2025), is based in the Netherlands (a 14 Eyes country) and its apps aren't open source. PIA has a no-logs audit by Deloitte (2025), is based in the United States (a 14 Eyes country) and its apps are open source.

How do Surfshark and PIA handle torrenting?

Surfshark allows torrenting on every server, without port forwarding. PIA allows torrenting on every server and offers port forwarding. Port forwarding helps you connect to more peers.

How many devices can I use with Surfshark and PIA?

Both allow unlimited devices at once. A router counts as one device.

Do Surfshark and PIA have a free trial?

Surfshark offers a 7-day free trial you start on its website for new users who choose a 12- or 24-month plan, with a payment method. It then works on any device, up to 3 at a time during the trial. Cancel before the trial ends to avoid being charged. PIA offers two free trials. A 7-day trial you start in the iOS app (App Store) with the annual plan only. A 3-day trial you start in the Android app (Google Play) with the annual or monthly plan. Surfshark's paid plans come with a 30-day money-back guarantee for your first purchase; it doesn't cover App Store and Amazon Appstore subscriptions, which Apple and Amazon refund under their own rules. PIA's come with a 30-day money-back guarantee; it doesn't cover Google Play and App Store subscriptions, which Google and Apple refund under their own rules.

Sources

Where the numbers come from

Scores use the published formula on our methodology page. Speed and streaming come from independent tests, not our own.